Why Auto Brokering Might Be Your Next Move (And Why I Haven't Looked Back)
You've hit your numbers again this month. You've smiled through another Saturday shift. You've navigated the tower, handled the objections, closed the deals. But lately, you've been asking yourself: Is this it?
If you're a car salesperson wondering what's next, I want to talk to you about auto brokering. Not as someone trying to recruit you, but as someone who made the switch and wishes I'd done it sooner.
The Truth About What You Already Know
You already know how to do this job. You understand inventory, financing, trade values, and customer psychology. You can read a deal sheet in your sleep and know exactly which lender will approve that 640 beacon.
But here's what you also know: you're building someone else's business. Every relationship you create, every repeat customer who asks for you by name, every referral you earn—it all stays with the dealership when you leave.
What Actually Changes (And What Doesn't)
What stays the same:
- You're still helping people buy cars
- You're still negotiating deals
- You're still using your expertise and relationships
- You're still getting paid when deals close
What changes:
- You work for your clients, not a dealership
- You keep your customer relationships forever
- You set your own schedule (actually, not just "flex time")
- Your income ceiling disappears
- You build equity in something you own
The Money Conversation Nobody's Having
Let's be real about income because that's probably your first question.
As a salesperson, you know the math: $200-400 per car, maybe more on premium units, plus bonuses if you hit 15-20 units. Good months you're at $8-10K. Great months maybe $15K. You're capped by floor time, inventory, and how many hours you can physically be at the dealership.
As a broker, you're typically charging $500-1,500 per transaction, depending on your market and service level. But here's the real difference: you're not splitting it with a house. You're not hoping the desk doesn't cut your gross. The fee you negotiate is your fee.
More importantly, there's no unit cap. I've had brokers tell me they closed 35 deals in a month working from home. Try doing that on a showroom floor.
What Your Day Actually Looks Like
Remember when you got into car sales because you liked helping people and making good money? Then remember how you ended up standing around for hours waiting for ups, sitting through sales meetings about hat rules, and begging for leads?
As a broker, your day looks different:
Morning: Coffee at home while you respond to client emails and do inventory searches. Maybe you have a call with a client at 9 AM to discuss their options.
Midday: You might meet a client at a dealership for a test drive you've arranged, or you're negotiating deals via phone and email with fleet managers you've built relationships with.
Afternoon: Working on deals, sending clients their options with your analysis, maybe doing a delivery.
Evening: Actually off. Unless you want to take a call. Because it's your business.
No tower. No floor manager asking where you are. No waiting for the desk to work your deal. No losing a Saturday with your family because you're "up."
The Part That's Actually Hard
I'm not going to sell you a fantasy. There are real challenges:
You need capital to start. Not a ton, but you need an LLC, insurance, maybe a business license depending on your state. Budget a few thousand to do it right.
The first 90 days are slow. You're building from zero. Your dealership database? Can't take it (legally). You're starting fresh. It's humbling after being a "top producer."
You have to generate your own leads. No more ups walking through the door. You need a website, social media presence, referral network. You become a marketer whether you like it or not.
Some deals you'll lose money on (at first). You'll spend 10 hours on someone who ghosts you. You'll negotiate a great deal and the client will buy somewhere else. You'll undercharge because you're still figuring out your value.
But Here's Why People Make The Jump Anyway
You own your reputation. When someone says "I only work with Sarah," they mean you, not the dealership you happen to work at.
You control your income. Want to make $20K this month? Take on more clients. Want to take three weeks off? Do it. Nobody's telling you your gross isn't enough or that you can't leave for your kid's game.
You're actually independent. Not "1099 independent" where you still have a desk manager and floor rules. Actually independent.
You help people differently. Instead of selling what's on your lot, you find exactly what they need from anywhere. Clients notice. Referrals follow.
It scales. Eventually, you might hire other brokers. Or create a referral network. Or develop specialty services. You're building something that can grow beyond your personal production.
The Question You Should Be Asking
Not "Should I become an auto broker?" but "What am I building toward in my current role?"
If you're building skills, relationships, and experience that you'll leverage into something bigger—whether that's management, GSM, eventually a dealership of your own—then stay. Learn everything you can.
But if you're just trading hours for dollars with no ownership, no equity, and a ceiling you've already hit? Then at least explore what else is possible.
What's Actually Stopping You
Every salesperson I know who's considered this has the same fears:
"What if I can't generate enough leads?"
You already know how. You've been doing it your whole career, you just called it "networking" and "building clientele."
"What if I fail?"
You can always go back to sales. Dealerships are always hiring good salespeople. You know this.
"What if I lose my income for six months?"
This is the real one. And it's valid. You need a financial runway or a way to do both for a while. But this is solvable.
The Real Question
You know how sometimes a customer comes in and you can tell they've already decided, they're just looking for permission?
Maybe that's you right now.
You already know you're good at this. You already know you're tired of splitting your income and building someone else's business. You already know there's a ceiling where you are.
So what's next?
